[Tf-curation] [TF-CMDI] next CMDI best practices meeting

[Alexander König]

Hi Menzo, Twan, et al.,

I went through the draft and only have a couple of remarks. I didn't get
around to do fancy PDF notes like Twan, so I will simply reference the
page/section.


general remark:
"middle priority" sounds really weird to me. I would prefer "medium
priority" instead

page 5:
- "if you have good local requirements" sounds a little bit weird, maybe
rather "good reasons to deviate from the recommendations"
- CLARIN provides the following tools and services 3. should say
"insight into the quality of CMD profiles"

page 14 top:
"these components are included in the group 'recommended' and can be
displayed in the standard component registry"
I see only two recommended components and one profile (when I search for
'recommended' in the search box). I assume the plan is to extend these.
Maybe the draft of the document should mention that this is also "in
progress".

P4:
"The CMDI allows"
The article, though technically correct, seems weird. I would remove it.

3.4:
"using tools such as CMDI Maker, COMEDI and Arbil"
Two of these are no longer developed, with the CMDI Maker only being
able to cater for 2 profiles, only one of which is actively used
(AFAIK). I think it would be good to mention this caveat here, so people
know what to expect.


best
Alex


On 11/09/17 16:43, Twan Goosen wrote:
> Hi Menzo, all,
> 
> Thanks for the updated version, nice to see the document already in a
> reasonably complete state! I have annotated the PDF version with a
> number of small remarks. None of them are really urgent, so they can
> also be considered for processing after the CAC.
> 
> A general thing that we have not discussed before IIRC: maybe it would
> be good to harmonise the mood of the 'titles' of the best practices.
> Now, some of them are imperative ('Include a MdSelfLink') while others
> are indicative ('The MdSelfLink should be a PID'). I like the former
> better although I don't have a strong preference either way, but I do
> think it would be nice to have a consistent style.
> 
> If you could send me a copy of the (Word) document towards the end of
> the week, I will print a few copies and bring them to Budapest so that
> people can have a look at the bazaar.
> 
> Best,
> Twan
> 
> On 08/09/2017 15:01, Menzo Windhouwer2 wrote:
>> Hi, All,
>>
>> You can find the latest version of the draft CMDI Best Practice guide (CE-2017-1076) here:
>>
>> 	https://datashare.rzg.mpg.de/s/dDvZZUl6YM1Tdyl
>>
>> Changes include:
>>
>> - Alignment in handling hyperlinks, references, etc.
>> - Removed impact of CLARIN B Centre requiements from the priorities
>> - Worked on reasons for high priority (needs references)
>> - Reassigned priorities (as proposed/discussed)
>>
>> Feedback is still welcome! Preferably early next week, so we can make it available on the CLARIN website on Wednesday, well in time for the CAC.
>>
>> Many thanks in advance,
>>
>> Menzo
>> --
>> www.meertens.knaw.nl/cms/medewerkers/144709-menzowi
>>
>> On 31/08/2017, 17:06, "Menzo Windhouwer2" <menzo.windhouwer at meertens.knaw.nl> wrote:
>>
>>     Hi, All,
>>     
>>     Thanks to all who could attend the meeting today!
>>     
>>     We’re about to finish the CAC abstract. There will be another review round before submitting it tomorrow. This round will be in round robin style among the participants of today’s meeting. Please contact me if you couldn’t make it today but still want to participate.
>>     
>>     Also the draft of the guide was discussed. Suggested changes will be incorporated and a new version will be send around next week. The main remaining point of attention are the priorities for the best practices.
>>     
>>     The next meeting will be a physical one:
>>     
>>     	18 September 2017, 11.30 - 13.00 CEST at the CAC17 in Budapest, Hungary
>>     	
>>     See also:
>>     
>>     	https://trac.clarin.eu/wiki/Taskforces/CMDI/Meeting20170918 
>>     
>>     Feel free to make suggestions for the agenda!
>>     
>>     Regards,
>>     
>>     Menzo
>>     --
>>     www.meertens.knaw.nl/cms/medewerkers/144709-menzowi 
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Tf-cmdi mailing list
>> Tf-cmdi at lists.clarin.eu
>> https://lists.clarin.eu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/tf-cmdi
>>
>